The Endangered Species Act is the country's strongest law for protecting imperiled wildlife; it's credited with keeping approximately 99% of listed species from going extinct.
ESA Protections: Endangered vs. Threatened
The ESA groups at-risk species into two general categories: threatened and endangered. Endangered species are presently at risk of extinction across all or a significant portion of their range, while threatened species are likely to become endangered in the foreseeable future. The category matters because it can determine how much legal protection a species receives.
Defining “Take” Under the ESA
Once a species is listed, certain protections apply regarding whether it's illegal to "take" or trade it without authorization. “Take" is defined as harassing, harming, pursuing, hunting, shooting, wounding, killing, trapping, capturing, collecting or even attempting any of the aforementioned.
Section 9 of the ESA bans “take” or trade of any endangered species and many threatened species within the U.S. and on the high seas.
Threatened Species and the ESA
Congress reasoned that threatened species are less imperiled, so it didn't extend full “take” protections to them automatically. Instead, section 4(d) lets the two federal agencies that administer the law, the Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, apply any or all of the endangered-species prohibitions to a threatened species. That could mean full protection, partial protection, or none at all – a flexibility NMFS uses more often than FWS.
The agencies have historically relied on two main approaches:
- The blanket rule which automatically extends the full section 9 “take” protections given to endangered species to threatened species as well. Only FWS has used this approach.
- Species-specific 4(d) rules that tailor protections to a single species, spelling out which activities are prohibited and which are allowed.
The blanket rules (one for animals, one for plants) were rescinded in August 2019, restored in 2024, and then rescinded again in July 2026. FWS historically used blanket and species-specific rules roughly equally. For the past decade, however, FWS has favored tailored rules.
Of the 361 threatened animal species listed under the ESA, 51% are covered by a species-specific 4(d) rule, a tool that has become increasingly used to manage, protect and conserve threatened species.
Given this shift, Defenders of Wildlife sought to evaluate 4(d) rules over the past 10 years, an extension of a report developed at Defenders back in 2017. The updated report, "Emerging Trends in Implementation of Section 4(d) of the Endangered Species Act: A New Era of Challenges and Opportunities," found that most rules could offer conservation benefits or have negligible adverse effects on species recovery, especially when mitigation is applied as a means to reduce the impact of certain activities. For some species, however, especially those facing industry or political pushback, the rules include exemptions that could hinder recovery.
Not Everything Is Off-Limits: What a 4(d) Rule Exempts
To meet the goals of the ESA, 4(d) rules should set a clear, predictable baseline of protections that allow activities that pose little to no threat to species, promote recovery, and, where appropriate, spare landowners and managers the burden of seeking a permit.
Some of these activities are conservation-focused, such as habitat restoration, captive breeding and reintroduction, and research and monitoring. These can technically “take” individual wildlife, but their long-term benefits can advance recovery.
Others are not driven by conservation goals but pose minimal risk to recovery when done in ways that don't harm particular wildlife, including bridge and culvert repair (which can remove passage barriers for aquatic fish), livestock grazing, fire management, sustainable silviculture and recreational angling.
When it Works: Compatible Land Use Practices
At their core, 4(d) rule exemptions should be carefully crafted and science-based, allowing for activities that are known benefits to species recovery or otherwise cause minimal adverse impacts to the species’ recovery prospects.
The elfin-wood warbler, listed in 2016, is a good example. The warbler faces habitat loss on private lands, particularly from agricultural clearing. Shade-grown coffee plantations, however, can provide nesting and foraging habitat and support greater biodiversity than sun-grown systems.
The warbler’s species-specific 4(d) rule therefore allows “take” for converting sun-grown plantations to shade-grown coffee, paired with mitigation measures that reduce disturbance during breeding season. The exemption lowers the regulatory burden for landowners who are already aligned with conservation incentive programs.
The Stephens' kangaroo rat offers another good example. The effects of livestock grazing vary by species and habitat, but this rodent prefers sparsely vegetated, disturbance-dependent grasslands, and research has shown that grazing in this habitat can coexist with the species with positive results. Its 4(d) rule reflects that exempting grazing when it’s done to benefit the species’ habitat and approved by FWS.
When It Doesn’t Work: Exempting the Very Threat That Led to Listing
Distinguishing insignificant impacts from consequential ones is difficult, especially under the political and industry pressure that surrounds listing decisions. That pressure can produce rules with inadequate safeguards against significant threats.
Our analysis found cases where section 9 "take” exemptions covered activities that could undermine recovery, and in some cases the very threats that led to a species’ listing were exempted.
As one example, the streaked horned lark’s 4(d) rule exempts, among other activities, agricultural practices in Oregon and Washington, even though agriculture is a significant threat to the species. FWS intended the exemption to ease burdens on farmers, since landowners can be reluctant to host listed species on their land. That goal is legitimate, but it cannot come at the expense of recovery, particularly when the exempted activity is a documented cause of decline.
The Path Forward: Rules That Work for Species and Landowners
Species-specific 4(d) rules can be strengthened to keep threatened species progressing toward recovery.
First, rules should use more mitigation, such as avoidance around sensitive habitat and restrictions during breeding, nesting, or migration, which can reduce impacts from minimally adverse to negligible. Second, they should avoid broad “take" exemptions for known threats, meaning activities that either drove a species’ listing or would push it further from recovery. Third, agencies should improve transparency, monitoring, and public guidance, since online platforms and similar tools can help landowners and the public understand what a rule allows.
Finally, adaptive management, though rarely used in 4(d) rules, should become standard. It can ease prohibitions as a species nears recovery if those prohibitions are no longer necessary to conserve the species, saving time and resources compared with waiting for a separate management plan to be updated.